KYVL: Information Skills Tutorial, Unit 4: Accuracy
Reliability
Information Skills Tutorial
Unit 4: Evaluation of Sources
Home | Previous Unit | Next Unit | Self-Test | Help
 Introduction 
 Start here 
 Unit 4 Contents 
Topic: Accuracy

Overview
Lesson
Examples
Quiz



Overview

We don’t usually think of published sources as having to be evaluated for accuracy. Magazine and journal articles are edited and checked for mistakes before they are published. The same is true of newspaper articles, government documents, books, and nearly every other type of source. However, our common assumptions are often incorrect.
Lesson

An unintentional error might slip into a document and then be multiplied by a hundred different newspapers (even though they quote it accurately). For this reason alone, you should always trace back important facts to their primary sources, or at least compare two different publications of fact.

It is always a good idea to double-check the accuracy of facts and statistics, but it is an essential step if you are using sources from the Internet. Web pages do not have to pass through any editor, fact-checker, or review process before being published. Anyone with a little technical knowledge and a host computer can publish web pages. It is entirely up to you to decide whether the information you find on the Internet is reliable. Here are some things to look for:

  • Sources for facts and statistics are provided so that they can be verified by you. (Read critically! Clever writers can make their opinions seem like facts.) Be wary of sites that rely on volunteers to provide factual information.
  • There is evidence that either an editor or other accountable person has checked for accuracy. For example, online editions of newspapers and magazines are likely to have editors; personal web pages are not.
  • The information is free of grammatical, spelling, and typographical errors.
  • If a particular piece of information is wrong, later issues of the page contain retractions or corrections.

Examples

Go to the web site called The Quotations Page. This is a convenient page for finding all sorts of quotations. But are the quotations accurate? Are they attributed to the correct people? Hint: click on their link to Contribute a Quotation and see how they add new quotations to the page. Then decide whether you would trust these quotations to be error-free.


Quiz

Which of the following is most likely to contain errors?
A. a newspaper
B. a scholarly article
C. a book
D. a web page

Which of the following would be helpful for you to verify a source’s accuracy?

A. citations
B. retractions
C. editorial credits
D. all of the above

Unit 4: 8 of 13


Last Updated: 05/26/2000
Email: KYVL Help Desk
Restricted Access
KYVL Help Desk: 1-877-740-4357